Keener Financial Planning

Keener Financial Planning is a Fee only Certified Financial Planner in Dallas, Ft. Worth, and Keller, TX. Call us to schedule today at (817) 993-0401.

817-993-0401 | [email protected]

  • About Us
    • Our Company
    • Our Services
    • Our Process
    • Meet our Team
    • Affiliations
    • Fee Schedule
    • Disclosure
  • Financial Planning
    • Planner Interview Questions
    • How Planners Are Paid
  • Resources
    • Client Log-In
    • Forms
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Hmm … Can Underperforming Assets Actually Help Your Portfolio Over Time?

September 22, 2013

The answer will probably be surprise you.

You’ve likely noticed that the U.S. stock market has offered booming returns over the past three or four years: up an average of 17.4% in the past 36 months alone.  Then you look at the money invested in international equities (the EAFE index up just 8.7% a year), bonds (the Barclay’s Aggregate Bond Index up 2.5% a year), and just about any other sector you could name, and it looks like they were holding you back.

Wasn’t that a huge opportunity cost in diversifying away from U.S. stocks?  Didn’t you lose money not being in U.S. stocks all that time?

Surprisingly, the answer is no.  In fact, a recent article in the Journal of Financial Planning offers a neat illustration showing why diversifying in a variety of assets–even though some inevitably underperform others–can actually raise your total portfolio returns over the longer term.

The article starts by pointing out the fact that positive and negative returns are not equal.  For small losses, they’re close: a 10% decline requires an 11% gain in order to get back the money you lost.  If you lose 20%, you have to gain back 25% before you have what you had before the market took a bit out of your portfolio.

But what if you lose 30%?  Now you have to get back 43% in order to have what you started with.

Lose 40% of your portfolio value, and you aren’t whole until you get a whopping 67% return on the remaining assets.  Lose 50% and, of course, you need a 100% return to get back to where you were.

The point?  If diversification minimizes extreme portfolio movements in either direction, it can lead to greater wealth creation–just because of the mathematics of gains and losses.

 To illustrate this, the authors produced an interesting chart.  They plotted the S&P 500’s returns from mid-1993 through mid-2013, which includes the thumping, roaring bull market of the later 1990s and two rather nasty market pullbacks.  Then they assume that somehow you would be able, via a broad asset mix, to reduce the downside by 50% and also give up 50% of every upside in the index–an even trade, right?

In fact, this strategy doesn’t look so great during the booming late 1990s, when the “tempered” index returns fell behind the market returns.  But over time, due to its outperformance during market busts, the tempered market returns produced more terminal wealth than the index itself.

Then the authors looked at what would happen if an investor did what many investors today are probably thinking about doing: abandoning those tempering, underperforming “other” investments and going all in on U.S. stocks.  They create a hypothetical investor named “Dick” who became very impatient watching his tempered portfolio underperform the index for the first seven years of the chart as the bull market roared through the investment world.  So he made a bold decision:  Banish diversification!  Full speed ahead with U.S. stocks!  He switched to the U.S.-only portfolio, and, as you can see on the graph, he has underperformed ever since.

 

Article adapted with permission of Financial Columnist Bob Veres.  The full study is available at http://www.fpanet.org/journal/RiskManagementasAlphaGenerator/

Filed Under: Investing, News, Your Finances Tagged With: diversifying your investments, Investing

Free E-Newsletter

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive free financial planning email updates. We'll never sell your address or spam you.

Latest from Facebook

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons
Keener Financial Planning
3 days ago
Keener Financial Planning

Happy Friday! As you head out to the weekend, we wanted to update you on how we're using AI at Keener Financial Planning. Please let us know of any questions! ... See MoreSee Less

Link thumbnail

How We're Using AI - Keener Financial Planning

keenerfinancial.com

We share how we're protecting client data security, ensuring continued accuracy and personalization, and seeking efficiency with AI.
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
Keener Financial Planning
4 days ago
Keener Financial Planning

A very helpful Q&A from Forbes on the provisions in the new law! This bill went through a lot of revisions, so Forbes covers some of the provisions that actually made it into the final version (and what didn't). ... See MoreSee Less

Link thumbnail

Answers To Your Individual Tax Questions About The One Big Beautiful Bill Act

advisorstream.com

Got questions about the new deductions for seniors, tips, overtime and car loans? Here’s what readers have been asking—and the answers—about those, as well as other updated tax provisions.
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
Keener Financial Planning
2 weeks ago
Keener Financial Planning

We will be closing at 3 pm today (7/3) and remain closed for Friday (7/4).

Wishing everyone a happy and safe 4th of July weekend!
... See MoreSee Less

We will be closing at 3 pm today (7/3) and remain closed for Friday (7/4).  

Wishing everyone a happy and safe 4th of July weekend!
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
Load more

Discuss if we’re a good fit for you

Contact Us

Main Office:

1692 Keller Parkway
Keller, TX 76248

Ph: 817-993-0401
Fax: 817-993-0002

Satellite Office:

2626 Cole Avenue, 3rd floor
Dallas, TX 75201

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

FORM CRS RELATIONSHIP SUMMARY (ADV Part 3) · Copyright © 2025 Keener Financial · All Rights Reserved