Keener Financial Planning

Keener Financial Planning is a Fee only Certified Financial Planner in Dallas, Ft. Worth, and Keller, TX. Call us to schedule today at (817) 993-0401.

817-993-0401 | [email protected]

  • About Us
    • Our Company
    • Our Services
    • Our Process
    • Meet our Team
    • Affiliations
    • Fee Schedule
    • Disclosure
  • Financial Planning
    • Planner Interview Questions
    • How Planners Are Paid
  • Resources
    • Client Log-In
    • Forms
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Who should consider Roth conversion

September 18, 2009

Given the historic opportunity of 2010 to spread the tax payment over 2 years in 2011 and 2012, everyone with a traditional IRA should take at least one look at Roth IRA conversion for next year.

It is most beneficial to you when all of these apply:

  • You’ll pay the resulting “conversion” tax with non-IRA funds
  • You have 10 years or more before you will be taking distributions from the Roth IRA
  • You will be in the same or a higher tax bracket when you start taking those distributions.

But even if only some or none of these apply, it doesn’t mean you should rule conversion out.  

There are still many times where it can make sense, and some that don’t.  It’s easiest to discuss these by looking at few examples.

I did an analysis for a 64-year-old who didn’t have the money to pay the tax with non-IRA funds, so the taxes were going to come out of his IRA.  He also only had 6 years until he planned to start taking distributions.  He was going to be in the same tax bracket in 2011-2012 and in retirement.  In his situation, he still came out ahead with conversion – having over $1,000 more in after-tax retirement income by converting.  He won’t be subject to the 10% penalty on the amount withdrawn to pay the tax because he is over 59 ½.  His situation was also helped by not planning to take social security until age 70.  If he was already receiving social security benefits, we would have needed to consider any additional income tax implications on his social security benefits for the years he claimed the conversion income.

Another analysis was for a 32-year-old woman.  She has a pre-tax employerworking-mom-happy-kid 401k and was also trying to decide if conversion made sense.  She also does not have the funds to pay the taxes with non-401k money, and she would be subject to the 10% penalty by withdrawing funds from the 401k before age 59 ½ to pay the taxes.  We estimated her tax bracket in 2011-2012 and in retirement as the same.  In her case, conversion did not make sense.  But it was quite close.  If she believed that her tax rates were going to be higher by the time she retired by even 1%, the conversion would have significantly increased her after-tax income.  

One last example – 44 year old.  He had a traditional IRA and had money to pay the taxes from a non-IRA account.  However, we estimated that his tax bracket in retirement would likely be lower than it is now, by about 3%.  In his case, conversion was still a great deal even with the projected lower retirement tax rate.  Having all those years of after-tax growth more than off-set the potential for a slightly lower rate in retirement.

If you have a traditional IRA, an analysis is in order. 

The above examples illustrate that even when your situation doesn’t meet the “ideal conversion” criteria, it still may make a significant difference in your after-tax retirement income.  If you’d like to see the specific calculations on any of the examples listed above, please feel free to contact me and I’d be happy to send them to you.

A few other considerations to keep in mind

If your estate is potentially subject to the estate tax, a Roth conversion can be a powerful planning tool. 

The market’s relative “high” or “low” value when you convert is also a factor in how good a deal conversion is – low values mean you pay tax on a lower amount. 

 There are also opportunities to convert in early 2010 and undo the conversion later based on circumstances or market performance.  We’ll discuss this in future posts.

Filed Under: Investing, Retirement, Taxes, Your Finances Tagged With: 2010 Roth Conversion, estate planning, IRA, Retirement, retirement income, retirement planning, Roth IRA, Roth IRA conversion

Free E-Newsletter

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive free financial planning email updates. We'll never sell your address or spam you.

Latest from Facebook

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons
Keener Financial Planning
3 weeks ago
Keener Financial Planning

Our Spring Financial Planning Newsletter with updated investment market perspective, advice on how to handle 401(k) rollovers during times of market volatility, estate planning for your pets, and more! ... See MoreSee Less

Link thumbnail

Spring 2025 Financial Planning Newsletter - Keener Financial Planning

keenerfinancial.com

Our Spring 2025 financial planning newsletter is now available. And there’s a lot to cover! We share tips for how to handle 401(k) rollovers during volatile market conditions and a TurboTax double-c...
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
Keener Financial Planning
1 month ago
Keener Financial Planning

Our office will close early at 3:00 PM today and remain closed through Friday in observance of Good Friday. We will reopen with regular hours on Monday.

Wishing you a safe and wonderful weekend!
... See MoreSee Less

Our office will close early at 3:00 PM today and remain closed through Friday in observance of Good Friday.  We will reopen with regular hours on Monday.

Wishing you a safe and wonderful weekend!
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
Keener Financial Planning
1 month ago
Keener Financial Planning

In the midst of a tumultuous period in the investment markets, Christine Benz with Morningstar, Inc. provides a great to-do list for investors. ... See MoreSee Less

Link thumbnail

What Now? An Investor’s To-Do List for Chaotic Markets

www.morningstar.com

A down market offers opportunities to check progress toward your long-term investing goals—and even save on taxes.
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
Load more

Discuss if we’re a good fit for you

Contact Us

Main Office:

1692 Keller Parkway
Keller, TX 76248

Ph: 817-993-0401
Fax: 817-993-0002

Satellite Office:

2626 Cole Avenue, 3rd floor
Dallas, TX 75201

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

FORM CRS RELATIONSHIP SUMMARY (ADV Part 3) · Copyright © 2025 Keener Financial · All Rights Reserved